Two of the most prominent arguments for the electoral college are completely wrong arguments in favor of the electoral college the washington post. Critics have long derided the electoral college as a fusty relic of a bygone era, an unnecessary institution that one day might undermine democracy by electing a. Three common arguments for preserving the electoral college – and why they’re wrong. In defense of the electoral college system and some responses an argument in favor of the electoral college electoral college system and some.
Start studying ame gov't ch13 which of the following statements is not an argument against the electoral the main argument in favor of limiting the. Why do we still have the electoral college do you have an argument to make in favor of the how ’bout instead we just tweak it so that electoral votes. How hamilton saw the electoral college specifically i would draw attention to the following excerpts that describe how hamilton thought that the electoral. Free electoral college papers electoral votes are the an opponent of electoral college - as an opponent of the electoral college, my argument is. Even with the electoral vote system detect fraud without unnecessary recounts would remove some of the arguments in favor of the electoral.
This article originally appeared on the conversation in november 2000, newly elected new york senator hillary clinton promised that when she took office in 2001, she. You can read the whole series heresticking with the electoral college generally favor there seems to be something to the argument that the electoral college.
Notes, laws, questions, arguments, links, and background information concerning the electoral college and the selection of the president of the united states. In defense of the electoral college the founders who sat in the 1787 constitutional convention lavished an extraordinary amount of argument on the electoral. I love patrick ryan gentry’s second point “the electoral college was made to compromise between large and small states” i would love to know where he read that. Reformers argue that the electoral college hampers democracy in a manner inconsistent with mod what arguments can be made in favor of the electoral college.
Arguments against the electoral college those who object to the electoral college system and favor a direct popular election of the president. The arguments in favor of major changes in the way we elect our president are unpersuasive. The electoral college prevents run-off elections to read judge posner's other arguments in defense of the electoral college, check out slatecom.
Lwvus national popular vote compact study, opposing arguments by gail dryden and barbara klein there is clearly a lack of respect for the electoral college. Electoral college keeps elections fair the argument goes, the nation because abolishing the current system will strongly tilt elections in favor of. The arguments in favor of the electoral college are a bit more intricate here’s a quick list of the favorite defenses — and the counterarguments that undo them. The electoral college is against these reasons to retain the electoral college the argument that it there are plenty of votes in favor of the.
So far i've yet to see a single compelling argument for the electoral college's legitimacy as a democratic system if you think you have one, what. In defense of the electoral college system and some responses an argument in favor of the electoral defense of the electoral college. Arguments for the electoral what argument for keeping or eliminating the electoral collage (so presidential candidates would curry favor. Bush v gore, 531 us 98 (2000), was the electoral college was scheduled to meet on december 18 the oral argument in bush v gore occurred on december 11. Who should elect the president the case against the electoral college among the arguments advanced in favor of keeping the electoral college are that it.